top of page
AlwaysPies
Our Menu


Always Pies
Always Pies
Pies available any time, every season! All fruit pies can have a Lattice, Full Top or Crunch Topping. Please indicate your preference.


Triple Berry
Blueberry, Blackberry and Raspberry delightfully combined!
$20
Triple Berry


Fresh Strawberry
Strawberry pie topped with whipped cream. Yum!
$20
Fresh Strawberry


Blueberry
A popular favorite
$20
Blueberry


Banana Cream
I'm running out of good descriptions lol
$20
Banana Cream


Apple
Apple pie, my favorite!
$20
Apple


Caramel Apple Crunch
Need I say more? :)
$20
Caramel Apple Crunch


Pumpkin
A seasonal favorite, available year round!
$20


Pecan
I am Bender, please insert girder
$20


Sweet Potato
Sweet Potato Pie with homemade marshmallow whipped cream, topped with pecans. Always homemade with fresh, quality ingredients! Always a taste of home.
$20
Sweet Potato



Autumnal Offerings
Autumnal Offerings
A tasty seasonal assortment! All fruit pies can have a Lattice, Full Top or Crunch Topping. Please indicate your preference.


Apple Cranberry
Yum!
$25


Spiced Chai Apple
Doesn't that sound amazing!
$25


Harvest Pie
A sweet blend of apples, cranberries, and cherries married with a hint of almond.
$25


Apple Butter Pumpkin
Made with Pecan crunch.
$25


Caramel Apple Bourbon
<drooling noises>
$25



Quiche and Such
Choose from spinach, ham, bacon, saute'd mushrooms, cheddar cheese, feta cheese, or anything your heart desires, really. (Prices may vary)


Strawberry Rhubarb
Available in spring and early summer
$25


Blueberry Peach
Available late summer and autumn
$25


Lemon Pie
Yeah, this might be a thing
$25

SeasonalPies
QuicheAndStuff

CONTACT US

Come Say Hi 👋

Orders Weekly closing Sunday.

Deliveries on Thursday!

Serving the Oconomowoc, WI, and surrounding areas.

Stay on the Sweet Side

Thanks for submitting!

Have Any Questions?

Thanks for submitting!

© 2020 by Sugar Plum Pie Company. Proudly created with Wix.com

Webmaster: Crashed and Burned Consulting

bottom of page